I will work with the subject to determine which traits accurately describe him or her and send that list to three persons chosen. These persons will agree not to reveal to you the personality traits listed. You will then submit your analysis to these persons and they will determine how accurate you are. I will publish on my skeptic's Dictionary site your analysis and their analyses of your analysis. What do you say, jack? Here is Jack's reply: Robert. Your proposal sounds like what is going on in Florida. I know nothing of who you will "use" in this study and, frankly, knowing your subconscious "goal i do not trust this proposal.
Free graphology test Online, handwriting, analysis!
For example, you say that personality is in the brain and therefore handwriting must reveal personality. This begs the question, jack. Where is the evidence that the brain determines one's maker personality and one's handwriting in such a way that when one writes, one's handwriting reveals one's personality? We all know that in a trivial sense this is true: one's writing has content and that content can reveal aspects of hiking one's personality. Given the fact that I have over 400 articles and several hundred comments posted on the Internet, my personality is an open book, so to speak. Or do you propose to uncover aspects of my personality that even i am not aware of? If so, how do we determine whether you are right? I have another proposal. I would like to submit to you a handwriting sample of a subject you know nothing about. I will have the subject copy three pages of a foreign language text, so you will not be given any hints about the subject from the content of the writing sample. You give me a list of personality traits that you think you can identify by graphology.
But the principles are exactly the same for shredder graphology. And, whether you realize it or not, when a document examiner is analyzing a document he/she is actually "looking" at their personality similarities or non-similarities. Since i am short on time, this is the challenge. If you believe handwriting means nothing, then you should not be reluctant to submit a three page sampling of your handwriting on unlined paper for analysis. Signed and a copy of your drivers license with your signature on it for verification that the handwriting is yours. Send to: Handwriting Analysis Inc 15740 Rockford road suite 220 Plymouth, mn 55446. I predict you will not submit it out of fear of facing the fact that handwriting analysis is real and is, in fact, the most powerful psychological tool we have. Jack cammarata, president Handwriting Analysis Inc. Reply: Jack, you seem to be a logical person, though your reasoning seems a bit peculiar in places.
I was skeptical of handwriting when accidentally exposed. Then investigated and realized it's tremendous significance. I can honestly tell you that what you write about handwriting analysis is totally incorrect. Beyerstein and the rest of those "skeptics" thesis are simply not designing their protocols correctly because they have no real knowledge of handwriting or handwriting analysis. Doesn't it strike you that this subject has been around for centuries, studied by scientists and some of the most intellectually acute people and continues? Universities throughout the world teach it and bestow degrees. These people are not stupid. They apparently can see what you cannot or inadequately test for. The principles of questioned Documents (forgeries) you seem to accept.
The "studies" you or whoever cite were performed by inexperienced graphologists many of whom i am quite aware. Your evaluators, not being experienced or knowledgeable, had no idea how poorly schooled these analysts had to have been. Did any of the analysts have 20 years experience? As an engineer for 36 years, i can tell you i would not have been analyzing handwriting for 23 years if there was nothing. But, again, you or whoever, fail to explain the significance of handwriting. And, that is very telling. It takes a long time to understand and gain insight into handwriting.
What your handwriting says about you - business Insider
Some facts to ponder plus a challenge: The brain is scientifically based because it is an organized system of repeatable functions called logic. That's what directs people's choices. Otherwise, it would be chaos. If you say, bunk, tell me how we could tiger have developed the sciences without a scientifically based brain. The fact is that everything in the universe is scientifically based, which of course includes your d handwriting.
You should know that. Personality is in the brain. Therefore, handwriting must reveal personality. And, as it turns out, many other things also like the physical condition of the a degree. It's not trees an x-ray. You know: ab, ac,.
My guess is that if you set up a challenge between a forensic document analyst, some people with much experience reading documents but no special training in handwriting analysis, and some expert graphologists, you would find that the kinds of details you have brought. Also, while it might be fudging the issue a bit, one might consider crossing sevens and using foreign language symbols as "content." Graphologists claim they don't use content to read personalities from handwriting; they use just the form of the writing, the shapes and slants. Anyway, graphologists are having a hard time of it these days since hardly anybody takes pen or pencil in hand to write. Comment on Brian Hales's comments from another reader: There is a glaring error. In one paragraph he describes an engineer's personality: Engineers, as you may also be aware, tend to have quirky (by "normal" standards) personalities, and have more type a personalities than most, and enjoy playing with technological gizmos. I don't see any evidence for this.
Where are the studies that show there is a specific "engineer personality". In 24 years of working at nasa with thousands of engineer's i've never become aware of any specific unique personality traits that I could assign to engineer's. Jr _, robert: Hilarious reading about how handwriting does not reflect a person's personality. The arguments presented conveniently do not explain what handwriting represents. It's either something or nothing. It can't be nothing by empirical conclusion. Therefore, it must be something. I would suppose you would think an ekg pattern was of the same ilk. Just a meaningless pattern.
Does, your, handwriting, express
I think a partial rebuttal by yourself describing these minimalist effects might make the article more correct, and also give a better understanding to the general public about phenomena such as confirmation biases. After all, if a person only sees, "There is online 0 reason to believe this as opposed to, "There is only negligible reason to believe this, but scrutiny reduces that then how can you expect that person to learn about confirmation bias, which is arguably more. Alternatively, it may also be better to state that graphology is no more accurate than a 15-second face-to-face conversation. Of course, i'll trust in you to do the research necessary to show just how valid or invalid my claims in this email are. Brian Hales tokyo institute of Technology reply: you can count. I'll get right. Though you seem to have made the point quite well, it would be better if we had some controlled studies to back. I'll see if I can find them.
Thus, anyone who knows a little bit about engineers, and a little bit about how engineers write, could deduce that maker i am an engineer by the way i write, and then guess a little bit about my personality. I am not an expert in how everyone else in the world writes, but it would not be too far of a jump to suppose that other occupations have similar writing habits. (There are also other modifications that I have made, to avoid confusion of my letters and Japanese script. If someone were intelligent enough to learn about these, he could guess that I have lived in Japan for several years and also be able to guess that Japanese culture has begun to rub off.). T hus, i feel that by analyzing handwriting, one should be able to determine with certainty that is better than pure chance (but not necessarily by much more) the personality of the person who wrote. Thus, i feel that your article's overall tone is incorrect. You state via a" that graphology is no better than chance.
officially educated background in handwriting, i do have quite the background on statistics, critical thinking, and the philosophy of science. After reading your article on graphology, i do not feel as though you have been fair enough. That is not to say that the claims of graphologists are not absurd, but I feel as though there are some better-than-random (not by much, though) chances of indicating personality by analysis of the handwriting. As mentioned previously, i am an engineer. As such, there are two specific modifications to my handwriting that i've adapted over the years. Specifically, i cross my "7"s, "Z"s, and "z"s when I write them, so as to avoid confusion with similar symbols such as, 2, Greek "tau and Japanese hiragana "te". A second modification is that I frequently draw the letter "l" (lowercase L) in cursive, even when the rest of my text isn't, so as to avoid confusion with "I" (capital i) and "1" (one). Now, although some people who are not engineers (or mathematicians or physicists or scientists) also make these modifications, such people are quite rare, and the vast majority of people who use this sort of writing are engineer-like people. Engineers, as you may also be aware, tend to have quirky (by "normal" standards) personalities, and have more type a personalities than most, and enjoy playing with technological gizmos.
Sales environments estate vary, this is something that is largely ignored but its crucial when it comes to hiring an effective sales person. Some people are more suited to one sales scenario than another and the environments vary considerably. For instance call centre sales on incoming calls is miles different from field sales to board members. So just because a sales person has performed in one environment doesnt mean they will perform in your environment. If you really want a better, more reliable sales recruitment experience then try the new Sales Style personality topic from peopleMaps. Whether you are a recruitment agency or a sales manager, you can quickly and easily use this peopleMaps Recruitment Application. It takes about ten minutes to set up and free trials will be provided. No software to install as its all delivered online. From Abracadabra to zombies, to the skeptic: i am contacting you with regards to your article on graphology.
What your handwriting says about your career
Recruiting sales staff is the most challenging of all recruitment. Its also the riskiest. Fewer people can make or break a company than a sales person. If you proposal get a good sales person they can win and keep customers, driving up your turnover in the process. If you get a bad sales person they can lose you loyal customers and drive your business into the ground. PeopleMaps has launched a new personality topic called Sales Style. It goes way beyond the usual personality report. Instead of just working on stereotypes, it actually tells you the natural sales style of each candidate. It also tells you the ideal sales environment for each candidate.